0

iPads vs Netbooks vs Laptops…

Screen shot 2011-03-22 at 9.53.23 AM

Last night I was lucky enough to be asked to participate in an EdTechCrew Podcast via Skype, which was a great experience! The EdTechCrew, which consists of Darrel Branson (The ICT Guy) and Tony Richards from itmadesimple.com, upload weekly discussions via PodCast on a whole range of topics all relating to digital education, technologies, web based tools, web 2.0 and much much more!

The topic of discussion, as you can see from the title of the this post, was a great one! The whole iPad / Netbook / Laptop debate! Via the Skype call which Darrel and Tony hosted, i was fortunate enough to be joined by Adam Brice (@adambrice), an Assistant Principal at Ringwood Nth Primary School who is doing great with with iPads as part of the DEECD iPads 4 Learning Trial.

We also had Narissa Leung (@rissl) who is the Ultranet Coach in the Goldfields Network of the Loddon Mallee Region who is also very Passionate about eLearning and all things Cyber Safety. Last by certainly not least was Brett Moller (@brettmoller) who is Head of Learning and Educational Technologies at King’s Christian College on the Gold Coast. Brett has an extensive knowledge of ICT and worked with schools through Australia, Asia and the US.

The chat started with an introduction from Tony about each of the speakers and then it was down to the nuts and bolts of what we were there for. Each speaker was given roughly 3-5mins to present their case about which piece of Technology they saw to be most beneficial to student learning and teaching practices.

Rather than bore you all with my recount of the evening i will add a link below, when it arrives, of the actual Podcast itself. All i will say for now is that all guest speakers spoke strongly about which device they believed was the best for students and their learning.

It was great to have such an easy going conversation about such a debatable topic and to have the opportunity to hear such great educators speak and hear their pasion for ICT was a great experience. One thing that i certainly took away was that it was awesome to to hear not so much about what digital device is the ‘best’ to use, but that digital devices were in fact being used with students! I strongly feel also that depending on your schools setting and student needs, which cohorts will be using the devices and for what purposes, the need for different devices is paramount.

I am sure that all of you have your thoughts on which device you feel is the best fit for student learning, weather you’re a fan of Apple Technologies or a lover of PC and Windows based devices, I am sure that this debate will continue to rage on and continue to challenge those of us who are avid about using and embedding technology in to teaching and learning programs!